Sunday, January 29, 2023
No Result
View All Result
TLTP NEWS
  • Login
  • Bayan-ul-Quran
  • About Us
  • National
  • World
  • RTI
  • Courts
  • SDGs
  • Recognized Universities – Law
  • Op-Ed
  • SCHOLARSHIPS
    • Higher Education Commission Pakistan
    • DAAD Scholarships
    • Scholarships USA
  • Services
    • Advertise With Us
    • Partner With Us
    • TLTP Content Service
  • Bayan-ul-Quran
  • About Us
  • National
  • World
  • RTI
  • Courts
  • SDGs
  • Recognized Universities – Law
  • Op-Ed
  • SCHOLARSHIPS
    • Higher Education Commission Pakistan
    • DAAD Scholarships
    • Scholarships USA
  • Services
    • Advertise With Us
    • Partner With Us
    • TLTP Content Service
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Home Op-Ed
By Muhammad Alee

Expeditious Civil Trials: A Fresh Perspective

Its time to get Order XV of the CPC implemented for dispensation of justice in real sense

TLTP News by TLTP News
September 22, 2022
in Op-Ed
0
Expeditious Civil Trials: A Fresh Perspective

Expeditious and inexpensive justice is need of the hour for social and infrastructure development

29
SHARES
204
VIEWS

The issues that plague the legal system of Pakistan are no secret; rather, the struggle is in the search for its cure. According to a former Judge of the August Supreme Court, the average civil trial has a lifespan of 25 years, meaning thereby that an average litigant has to spend effectively one third of his or her lifetime litigating a single civil dispute, all the way from the civil courts (‘Katcheri’) to the Hon’ble Supreme Court of Pakistan.

This excessively slow justice system is, amongst other things, repulsive for business investors, local or foreign. Lack of investment, in turn, leads to low productivity, which, in turn, leads to poverty and lack of export competitiveness.

READ ALSO

Generation Gap or……….?

Quaid in conduct!

It is often assumed, incorrectly, that the root of the evil lies in our colonial era civil procedure and the only solution to this issue lies in rewriting the Civil Procedure Code, 1908. This view is mistaken and not just because the results promised are utopian and the task itself daunting. It is mistaken view because it is based on a complete ignorance of the nuances of the Civil Procedure and is premised on a failure to read the Code holistically and purposively.

 The purpose of this piece is to draw the attention of the wider legal community towards the Supreme Court’s recent and insightful judgment in the Nausher cases which creates hope for quicker resolution of at least those disputes where pre-trial documentary evidence is sufficient and conclusive. 

There is, however, a recent judgment of the Supreme Court of Pakistan which points out a pathway for reform which is both doable and pragmatic.  In Nausher v. Province of Punjab, etc (CA No. 1011 of 2016), authored by Justice Yahya Afridi, the Court has pointed out that even in the existing Code, there lies  to a hidden gem, lost in this era of haste – Order XV of the CPC – which makes it possible to decide summarily many of those disputes which are presently decided after prolonged trials.

The irony is that this massively important judgment has gone unreported and has largely escaping the attention of the legal community at large, whose entire focus is unfortunately on the Court’s politics, rather than it’s jurisprudence. What this omission says about the decay in our legal discourse is the subject of another column. However, the object here is to dwell on the insights offered by this judgment which signifies an important step towards reform of our civil justice system.

The factual controversy in the Nausher case related to mutations of the suit property, located in Tehsil Mianchannu, in favor of a deceased individual. The issue as to the veracity of the impugned order in question, alleged by the appellants as lacking force due to insufficient recording of evidence, was settled by the Supreme Court of Pakistan in light of Order XV, holding that the statements of the parties along with the record of prior proceedings of the case are sufficient. Effectively, the Supreme Court held that the legality of an order passed by a Court relying on such documentary evidence as the Judge deems sufficient for adjudication is within the four corners of the law. For the litigant, such adjudication is within the four corners of justice.

Order XV CPC, Civil Judge, Supreme Court of Pakistan, Top court Justice Yahya Afridi, Civil Procedure Code
The writer Muhammad Alee is Islamabad based lawyer

Under Order XV, most necessary evidence required to adjudicate the matter can be gathered even before the trial even begins. This is possible since Order XV empowers the Civil Judge to dispose the suit based on the record brought before it through pleadings of the parties and such other discovery as is conducted by the judge himself. This procedure is quite akin to what is already in vogue in the High Courts while carrying out judicial review of executive or legislative action. Without recording further evidence on the issues, the High Courts regularly rely on admitted documents appended with the Petitions and the Replies (and any Applications thereafter) as part of the record, and adjudicate upon the matter without further ado. If the High Courts can dispose cases in such a manner, and this doesn’t offend anyone’s sense of procedural propriety, why can’t he Civil Courts do the same? There is nothing radical about the Supreme Court’s observations about the importance of effectively utilizing pre-trial evidentiary tools.

The experience of civil justice reform all over the world shows that the system can function smoothly only where the vast bulk of cases are decided on the basis of pre-trial evidence, gathered under the supervision of a proactive judge. Concepts such as “discovery”, “interrogatories” and “notice to admit documents”  were not initially a part of Anglo-Saxon civil procedure which was based on truly adversarial procedure. But these concepts were adopted and amalgamated by the English jurists in the 19th century through interaction with German civil procedure and were already enshrined in our 1908 code. However, katchehri culture in the sub-continent never really took advantage of these innovations even after 1908. Almost 120 years later, any mention of pre-trial evidence continues to be something of an ‘innovation’.

Anyway, the purpose of this piece is to draw the attention of the wider legal community towards the Supreme Court’s recent and insightful judgment in the Nausher cases which creates hope for quicker resolution of at least those disputes where pre-trial documentary evidence is sufficient and conclusive. The author also wishes to urge the wider legal community to dwell upon those provisions of the CPC such as Orders X to XV which have remained ignored in Pakistan even after a century of their promulgation.

TLTP News

The Law Today Pakistan, commonly known as TLTP, is the largest news wire service, headquartered in Islamabad. The service is providing fast, comprehensive and verified news on superior courts adjudications, regulatory framework of fiscal, monitory and external sectors, economic regulatory bodies amid apex institutions regulating the financial system. TLTP is empowering readers of more than 12 national English dailies in the country.

Tags: Civil JudgeCivil Procedure CodeOrder XV CPCSupreme Court of PakistanTop court Justice Yahya Afridi

Related Posts

Professor Muhammad Siddique Qamar, PPP, PML-N, PPP, Imran Khan
Op-Ed

Generation Gap or……….?

September 13, 2022
Unethical Practices, Honesty, Principles, Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Supreme Court of Pakistan, OSD, NEPRA, National Electic Power Regulatory Authority, Civil Court, High Court, World Cup, Unconstitutional Acts
Op-Ed

Quaid in conduct!

July 7, 2022
Bilawal, Mian Nawaz Sharif, Pakistan Muslim League-N,Pakistan People Party (PPP), former Prime Minister Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto
Op-Ed

All Eyes On Bilawal Bhutto

April 26, 2022
Russo-Ukrainian War, Turkey, President Tayyip Erdogan, Black Sea, NATO, Dmytro Kuleba, Mevlut Cavusoglu, Vladimir Putin
Op-Ed

Time to support Ankara for peace in Eurasian Region

March 8, 2022
Customs, Federal Excise, Sales tax, Income tax laws, Finance Bill, Pakistan, Federal Board of Revenue, Benami, Anti Money Laundering, Superior Court of Pakistan, Supreme Court of Pakistan, Tax, Special Litigation Management Resource Centre Special Litigation Management Resource Centre
Op-Ed

Challenges of Tax Collection – The Way Forward

February 27, 2022
Dr Mehdi Hasan, Punjab University, Journalism,
Op-Ed

Meeting Dr Mehdi Hasan

February 27, 2022
Next Post
Chief Justice of Pakistan Justice Umar Ata Bandial, Chief Justice Islamabad High Court Justice Athar Minallah, 9th International Judicial Conference, Supreme Court of PLaw and Justice Commission of Pakistan (LJCP), National Judicial Policy Making Committee (NJPMC), Pakistan,

Political impasse does not have legal solutions, CJP

POPULAR NEWS

Punjab, PTI, Governor Punjab Balighur Rehman, Lahore High Court

PTI urges LHC directives for elections schedule in Punjab

January 27, 2023
Election Commission of Pakistan, Pakistan Penal Code, Fawad Chaudhry, Adaila Jail Rawalpindi, PTI, Imran Khan, Judical Magistrate Islamabad Waqas Ahmed Raja

Fawad Ch to Adiala Jail in sedition case

January 27, 2023
British High Commission Islamabad,Ramada Hotel, State of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, Pakistan, United Kingdom, Forensic Evidence, Advocate Sharafat A. Chaudhry

ASJ directs Police to conduct probe into cold-blooded murder of UK national in Ramada Hotel

June 25, 2022
Peshawar High Court, Federal Board of Revenue, Barister Umer Ijaz Gilani, Advocate Hamza Bangash, Income Tax Ordinance 2001, Demand Rental Income of Property, Ahmed Kundi

PHC issues notices to FBR and others in plea challenging vires of 7E ITO 2001

December 14, 2022
Advocate Sharafat A Chaudhry, Ramada Hotel Islamabad, Bradford biochemist Farooq Ali, Islamabad Police, Neurologist Rehiana Ali, British High Commission, Forensic Evidence, Pakistan, Ramada Hotel, State of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, United Kingdom

Waiting for due justice over murder of UK national Biochemist Farooq in Islamabad

December 18, 2022

EDITOR'S PICK

Film Industry, Entertainment, Politics, Internet, Law, Media And Communication, Ethics, Telecommunications, School Systems, Finance

AMPAS reviews Oscar campaigns

January 29, 2023
Election Commission of Pakistan, Pakistan Penal Code, Fawad Chaudhry, Adaila Jail Rawalpindi, PTI, Imran Khan, Judical Magistrate Islamabad Waqas Ahmed Raja

Fawad Ch to Adiala Jail in sedition case

January 27, 2023
Punjab, PTI, Governor Punjab Balighur Rehman, Lahore High Court

PTI urges LHC directives for elections schedule in Punjab

January 27, 2023
NilofarBkhtiar NCSW chairperson, NCSW, Ramada Murder case, Civil Procedure Code, Islamabad Capital Police, Dr Rehiana Ali, Farooq Ali, UK, Legal Advisor NCSW Sharafat Ali Chaudhry, Secretary NCSW Arif Anwar Baloch,

NCSW seeks report over murder of UK-Kashmiri national

January 15, 2023

About

TLTP NEWS

TLTP News - An Independent News Wire Service

Follow us

Categories

  • Commodities
  • Courts
  • Currencies
  • Financial Institution
  • Latest
  • National
  • Op-Ed
  • Pakistan Stock Exchange
  • Right to Information
  • Scholarships
  • Uncategorized
  • World

Recent Posts

  • AMPAS reviews Oscar campaigns
  • Fawad Ch to Adiala Jail in sedition case
  • PTI urges LHC directives for elections schedule in Punjab

Latest News

Film Industry, Entertainment, Politics, Internet, Law, Media And Communication, Ethics, Telecommunications, School Systems, Finance

AMPAS reviews Oscar campaigns

January 29, 2023
Election Commission of Pakistan, Pakistan Penal Code, Fawad Chaudhry, Adaila Jail Rawalpindi, PTI, Imran Khan, Judical Magistrate Islamabad Waqas Ahmed Raja

Fawad Ch to Adiala Jail in sedition case

January 27, 2023
  • World
  • About Us
  • Partner With Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Latest

All Content is Copyrighted © 2021 TLTP News

No Result
View All Result
  • Bayan-ul-Quran
  • About Us
  • National
  • World
  • RTI
  • Courts
  • SDGs
  • Recognized Universities – Law
  • Op-Ed
  • SCHOLARSHIPS
    • Higher Education Commission Pakistan
    • DAAD Scholarships
    • Scholarships USA
  • Services
    • Advertise With Us
    • Partner With Us
    • TLTP Content Service

All Content is Copyrighted © 2021 TLTP News

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In